sun sign and homoeopathy

I know that the homeopath Robin Murphy has also done some research into this area.

Mode of administration is no different. It will be decided based on each patient's sensitivity level, etc.

this area is not trusted yet--though for the keen --tehy would have taken this in account on a clinical(perspective)--then noticing after many cases --trends -tendicies of remedies and things such as excat start ailments-sun-moon--in birth chart---but what is also considered (not easily founded) is conception sun/moon positions---apllicatins to zodiac signs --is sall ind way--precision of allignments--times and such---scientific approach is only way we can advance--not guess work--which is tendency--such as what ongroling of homoeopathy has become---much easier to guess and seem to know --than study and apy KNOWN principles---

How about swinging a pendulum to ascertin the correct remedy, or even asking our pets! We could then write the name of the remedy on a piece of paper and put it in our pockets, it's sure to work, no need to take it!

My god, what's next...praying to the Tibetan god of whirling derbishes for a prescription?

man is curious by nature and there is nothing wrong in carrying out a reserch on this subject.

as each sun sign subject has his inherent 'nature' as each remedy-personified has.

this information would be handy to all, either the physician or the self prescriber, though not binding.

final selection could be made based on thermals or sun signs if there is a confusion.

There is a saying Mr Rishimba, 'there is open mindedness, and then there is being so open minded that our brains fall out', I find it's a good analogy concerning such things as the above.

'final selection could be made based on thermals or sun signs if there is a confusion.'
Or lack of ability to find the similium in the proper manner?

Even sun signs are not pure, there are cusps and plantes gradually shift to constillations.

Yes bell for cancer, platina/ lyco for leo, puls for libra, phos for gemini. Only this much is sure.

Sure it will be amusing to discover more but only for the amusement purposes.

We taked aboyut that for fun in another homeopathic forum (I have never seen any serious studies about that--but I am sure there will be in nearest future)
and we chose lachesis for Scorpio, causticum for Sagittarius, Sepia for female Aquarius, sulphur was for Aries and ale Aquarus

We also chose platina for Leo and phos for gemini but lyc. for cancer and puls. for Pisces (my father was libra and hei const. was nux vomica
it is fun! (but why anyone posts here to trumpet his lack of interest in it? Nobody cares if you do not like it. Just have some decency to NOT post in this thnread!)
virgo was arsenicum

Wow, I made lots of typos-sorry!
And so:
taked=talked
ale=male
hei=his
thnread=thread

I am sorry Mr/Ms Astra2012, are you speaking to me?

I am speaking to everybody who feels obliged to let anyone know he or she is not interested in the topic. Who cares?
(either in the topic of the particular thread like.g. this one, or in the homeopathy at all: like so called sceptics).
It's everybody's right to believe or disbelieve---however the threads or whole forums are made for whomever is interested. Only. It is amusing however, how some people believe anyone cares what they think if they have nothing to contribute here.

Well do let me know if you find such a person won't you? My purpose of posting on this thread is to expose how ridiculous such methods being propagated by those with their heads in the clouds really are. 'Belief' is always irrelevant, especially in science.

If you want to practice astrology, pratice astrology, but don't try to pollute Homoeopathy with such non-factual and unscientific beliefs.

the reason why some people know much beyond their profession is their openmindedness and accept new ideas.

conservative and orthodox people who cling on to their own professional knowledge and are reactionary by nature miss out on so mant things this world has given us to explore.

organon, when you look back at your life, will you not feel .. i wish i could know something more than classical homepathy !!

either astrology or lets say.. robotics.

open and scientific mind is needed--2 MUST exist for benefit of the goal--'''to heal --gently---with as such speed as no harm occur--and permanently------''

one must remeber all scientific facts in theoi beginning were not norm--and throuh open scientific mindful appraoch --knowledge was/is gained---this applies in all aspect--who is to say whee we stop or start---yet better to keep goal in mind---if to heal then no use dabbling in such things what zodiac sign can be fit into what reedy--or vice versa---if goal is to learn this aspect applied wth homoeopathy then firstly the practitioer must be well versed in the basic principles and can heal the deepest of cases with surety --and know when case is not curable---so in truth --this is an idle topic --of no real use for busy practitoner--but it is with the busy practioner of homoeopathy that can give light on this --after years of case taking and noting each case and each background history of every patient--this is science---wise we treat it as such---yet nothing wrong with pretending one knows --or thinks they know --or fantasy about this and that--again we were warned of this--and such speculations to be aplied as truth is old --''materia peccans'---for homoepathy to takeits rightful place we all need be very scientific yet open mindedly---so those who like the zodiac idea--then include this aspect in ur full case histiry--alog with all detail u can gather----in toie u ay be able apply scientifcally based on empirical facts---tell --what is wise ?

Many people believe astrology is not scientifis (without knowing much aabout it!) and many people believe that also about homeopathy.
So be it. Who cares!

Invading threads about astrology/homeopathy to declare one's negative opinion without contributing anything else is exactly as rude as coming to the homeopathic forum to trumpet one's negative opinion about homeopathy. Such forums and such threads are created for pepople who share interest in something - not to provide a little exciteement in anyone's pathetic empty life.

I think we 'assigned' Anacardium to capricorn

Aries was also Argentum nitricum

I would be very interested to find any research on sun sggns vs remedies that help however the 'pressure' from ignorants might be too strong for anyone to undertake such research.

Anyone knows of such studies?

In Robin Murphy's Lotus materia medica he assigned planet to materia.

Sum sign tells much about personality and usually it is correct. Many times I anticipate a person's sun sign. ie. sagittarius can be having horse like hanging hairs at his forehead. Taurus is always around women. Leo is purely stupid ego.

So remedies indeed fit to the personalities.

Of course they do! Sometimes sun sign is very clear and I guessed it immediately, sometimes moon sign is quite strong-and shows through.(so it may be not thatt easy to see the sun sig but sooner or later it shows.

I have Murphy's Lotus MM with planets for each remedy I have never read the meaning of them. I thought t has something to do with collecting the material.

I'll try to write something good about these signs
like leo may be vain and haughty like platina but they have charisma (are often leaders)
And Taurus is good with finances (we had problem picking remedy for Taurus; veratrum?)
When a man does not pay much attention to his clothes and generally the way he looks-Aquarius, (but maybe also Aries and Sagittarius-)--Sulphur

And if someone loves conflict-Scorpio? snake remedies?

I will read Murphy more carefully Thanks.

the reserch can be made by some of us to start with.

each one of us need to come up with some comparison and then we can make a nice document, which will be useful for all..

for me, it matches so well..

i am a phosphorus by constitution and gemini by sun-sign.

my brother is a leo and he is a lycopodium by nature.

this is definitely a potential subject for further refinement of ideas..

great thread..:)

Taurus old age is bad, severe arthritis etc.

So what could be a preventive remedy?

I do not think arthritis is a Taurus thing (and neither is old age).
But imo there is a definite correlation between sun sign and const. remedy because both r vry much based on mind/personality.

I have no idea what that would be for Taurus...

It is a scientific fact that OX gets severe arthritis, they are all found roaming around all over in India, mostly invalid due to arthritis. All Taurus I know got arthritis even before they hit 40.

Leo is depression at the end of line. There is always the end of line for us all.

Wow! Frankly I didn't know that. I don't know that many Taurus people.

In Murphy's Lotus MM Aurum is associated with Leo---depresion?

I'll check Taurrus in a while.

With a Leo, he spends life to show -- at the end, it is the end of show. So depression. Astrology wise also Leo and Taurus old age is worse.

Leo lady is real gentle lady, a hard working one. She-lion does all the work, raises the kids, hunts. But Lion even steal from his kids and lady.

Taurus also fits Phosphorous, For Taurus rheumatic complaints, probably phosphorous is preventive.

Amusing once I was with my friend Dr. Jagjiit Singh. A very famous unqualified homeopathy doctor. His name is famous in 200 miles circle. Just take his name and directions to access him will be given. We call him Dr. Jeet.

Dr. Jeet was telling me the difference between Phosphorous personalities.

Causticum is a genuine leader, causticum will go fight for whatever he feels right. As Gavini claims to be a Causticum

Phosphorous is a leader too but a very clever one. His leadership is his ambition. When he is fighting for some cause, he is only fighting for his ambition. On any symptoms of trouble he is nowhere to be found at the front-line. He is hidden behind others. He is first to escape. But Causticum is not there to escape but to fight even if he is left alone.